The Education Revolution No One Saw Coming
In March 2020, American education changed forever. Overnight, parents became co-teachers, dining rooms became classrooms, and “school” took on a whole new meaning.
When the dust began to settle, families started asking a hard question: Is public education still the best option for my child?
For millions, the answer was no.
Pre-pandemic: 3.4% of U.S. school-aged children were homeschooled.
2020–2021: That number nearly tripled to 9%.
Today: Around 6.73% — an estimated 3.7 million — are still learning at home.
Parents aren’t just turning to independent homeschooling. Many are enrolling in public charter school programs with flexible online or hybrid models, while others are seeking private schools that align with their values and priorities.
Why Parents Are Walking Away from Public Education
1. Politics in the Classroom
A 2023 Pew Research Center survey revealed that only 16% of Americans believe public K–12 education is headed in the right direction. Over half (54%) pointed to teachers and staff introducing personal political and social views into lessons.
For many families, this shift has pulled education away from timeless principles — virtue, truth, honor — and toward agendas that feel out of step with their values.
2. Less Time on Core Subjects
Excessive focus on standardized tests has narrowed the curriculum. Creativity, critical thinking, and problem-solving often take a back seat.
Large class sizes and one-size-fits-all methods make it hard to meet individual needs. Parents notice — 69% say schools don’t spend enough time on essentials like reading, math, science, and social studies.
3. Underfunded and Overcrowded
Funding gaps between districts mean some schools have advanced tech and small class sizes, while others lack basic supplies. Teachers are leaving at record rates, with most exiting within five years — a churn that disrupts learning for every scholar.
4. The Results Speak for Themselves
The 2025 National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) paints a sobering picture:
69% of 4th graders and 70% of 8th graders are not proficient in reading.
61% of 4th graders and 72% of 8th graders are not proficient in math.
A typical U.S. student spends 8,884 hours over nine years to complete elementary/lower secondary education, which is nearly 1,300 hours more than the average for other countries. This is approximately 50% more hours than Finland, for example, which has 15 minutes of recess every hour, requires no standardized tests besides PISA in high school, and outperforms the U.S. every time, in every learning domain.
According to the latest National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) exam scores, released in January 2025, low student academic performance scores only further solidify the stance that U.S. government education is systematically broken.
Where Parents Are Turning Instead
With dissatisfaction rising, families are choosing options that prioritize both academics and character:
School choice programs that give parents control.
Mission-driven education from institutions like Hillsdale College and PragerU.
Charter schools and online academies, such as John Adams Academy and John Adams Academy Online, combine rigor with flexibility.
As education policy advocate Keri Ingraham states:
As a nation, we can no longer justify restricting children to these failing schools…Change is urgently needed. And that change will require competition.
The Bottom Line
America’s education system has been showing cracks for decades — the pandemic simply pulled back the curtain.
Parents now have choices. Scholars deserve better. And the future of our nation depends on whether we plant the seeds of truth, leadership, and excellence in the next generation.
Our garden of education has withered and wilted for long enough. It is time to pull out the weeds.
____